Welcome to Casey’s Sullivan, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Sullivan, IL, at 320 S Hamilton St. This cozy pizza joint is not just a place to grab a bite; it's a community hub where delightful food meets exceptional service, creating an experience that keeps locals coming back for more.

When you step inside Casey's Sullivan, you're greeted by more than just the aroma of freshly baked pizza. The friendly staff, consistently praised in customer reviews, ensures every guest feels welcomed. One of the standout features of Casey’s is its commitment to great customer service; as noted by satisfied patrons, the smiling faces behind the counter make even the busiest days feel a little brighter.

• Signature Pizza: Casey's Sullivan offers an array of delicious pizzas that cater to every palate. From classic cheese to adventurous taco pizzas, they promise to satisfy your cravings. While reviews are mixed about specific toppings (some customers mentioned missing salsa and beans), the overall consensus praises the quality of their dough and the appropriateness of toppings.
• Unique Specialties: Beyond pizza, Casey’s is also celebrated for its mouth-watering doughnuts, which have earned accolades as "the best in town" from loyal customers. Imagine starting your day with a warm, fluffy doughnut paired with your favorite coffee.
• Shareable Sides: Don't overlook the Shareable Mac and Cheese, a dish rich in flavor and creamy goodness. Topped with melty cheddar, it’s perfect for sharing or indulging solo!

In the vibrant dining atmosphere, Casey's Sullivan doesn't just fill your stomach; it satisfies your soul. The homey environment and the passion for quality food blend beautifully, making every visit a comforting escape from the hustle and bustle. Whether you're stopping in for a quick meal or taking the family out for pizza night, Casey's Sullivan has something for everyone.

The stories told by patrons and the smiles around the dining area reaffirm that this is not just a pizza place — it’s a beloved local destination. If you find yourself in Sullivan, don't miss the chance to indulge at Casey’s Sullivan. A taste of their pizza and a bite of their doughnut truly encapsulate what it means to enjoy good food in good company.